The Wilco show at The Lyric was interesting, to say the least. It has spawned three articles that I’m aware of related to people talking in the crowd and Jeff Tweedy’s reaction to said talking.
My take on it is this. Good luck getting 1,300 people who are drinking in a bar to be quiet, especially at a show that is kind of a rock show half the time. To get a crowd that big to shut up and be quiet and listen, as I guess Jeff expected, he needs to give them chairs. That seems to be a little bit of an unwritten rule here. Give us chairs and we’ll be quiet. Thacker Mountain Radio and Music in the Hall are good examples of that.
The second thing I’ll say is that it’s up to you and your performance to get that many people to shut up. If your show does not command their attention, it’s kind of your fault as much as it is theirs. Bitching about it is only going to take away from the experience of those that are within a close radius and listening intently.
I went to the Dent May show at Proud Larry’s this weekend, and he kicked ass. The show was amazing. What a voice. And what songwriting. He was playing at a bar and a few people were talking during the show, because they were AT A BAR. But Dent didn’t give a damn, and the whole band looked to be having as much fun as the people in the crowd.
I must say this; Wilco is one of my top 10 or 15 bands to listen to in my car or at work or wherever. I love their albums. But they are just an OK live act. I’ve only been to four shows: one at the old Library, the Orpheum in Memphis, the Ford Center here, and now at The Lyric, but it has hit me that Wilco just doesn’t do it for me live.
Some bands are “get down” bands, and some are “sit down.” Wilco falls somewhere in between, and that’s where the problem lies with their live shows, in my opinion. It’s really more of a sit down (or stand there) and listen show, but that just can’t be achieved in a bar in Oxford with 1,300 people standing and drinking.
I’ve seen some great “sit down” shows in Oxford. The best ever for me was Gillian Welch and David Rawlings at Proud Larry’s in 2003. The show, billed as “The David Rawlings Machine” in The Oxford Town, had only about 150 people show up, because only the diehard Gillian fans and those who heard the whispers knew that if David was playing, she was too. He is her husband and a bad ass picker, by the way. So it worked out perfectly and everybody sat at tables or at the bar, and it was literally one of the top 3 shows I’ve ever seen. Could have heard a pin drop in that place. For Tweedy to expect that kind of atmosphere from 1,300 standing, drinking people is ridiculous.
With about an hour left in the Wilco show, I found myself craving some Rocket 88 (playing at Proud Larry’s). So I decided to sneak away just for a couple songs. I found a great crowd and a great vibe, and realized really quickly that I was having a lot more fun that I had been at the Wilco show. But I decided to get back over to The Lyric to catch the encore after my little thirty minute or so break. As I was walking back, I ran into a half dozen or so friends who were headed to Larry’s themselves (no encore for them), and I decided to do a u-turn and join them. We had so much fun at a show that one could have predicted would have been dead, on the same night of such a big show a couple blocks away. Rocket 88 just keeps getting better and better and better. I love it.
I guess the moral of my story is, if you put on a show that commands the audience shut up (and it helps if you give them a chair), they’ll shut up. If you don’t and they don’t, please don’t bitch about it; that only gives the show a bad vibe.

Dent May and His Magnificent Ukulele at Larry’s 5.1.2009
Filed under: Entertainment, Music, Oxford Life
Recent Comments